I've seen the look, the one you get for passing up the Missouri and the Skwala hatch on the Big Hole to fish for carp. I get it. I like big trout too. But not enough to give up a chance at casting to a fish with its head down, tail up, and feeding in shallow water.
I blame redfish and the Cape Fear Coast for that. But why carp? Maybe, I somehow sub-consciously settled for redfish's fat, ugly cousin, carp. Or maybe, I have no standards. Or maybe, I just miss seeing oyster beds and half-submerged spartina grass off the bow of the boat. But the simple truth is, carp are the saltiest fish I've ever fished for in freshwater. And the last time I checked, saltwater is pretty hard to find in the great expanse between the continent's mountain ranges. But it's out there. If you don't believe me, I could suggest some delightful beachfront property in SW Montana. You might have to wait 15 minutes for a rancher to herd 500 head of cattle across the road to get there, but trust me, it's out there.